In 2005, an electronic organ was purchased to replace the pipe organ which had not been functioning in recent years. Although many people gave donations toward the new organ, the dedication was made in memory of Billy Sheesley, a longtime member who used his time and talents on countless occasions to maintain and improve the church property, and in honor of Paulette Palmer, whose efforts and sacrifices made the purchase of the new organ possible.
In 2006 a capital improvement campaign began to renovate the existing structure and to create plans for a future education and recreation building to be built. Architects were employed and members and the minister, Michael S. Morris, met to lay the groundwork. By April, 2008, the former church office, (which at one time was the church parsonage) was completely torn down and the rental house purchased by the church in 2002 (on the corner of Centralia and Ethel Road) was renovated to house the new office and conference room. Almost all of the work on the building was done by church members, from tearing down walls to hanging sheet rock, installing tile flooring, new wiring, heat and air, to all the painting and decorating.
In addition to the new office building, the parking lot was expanded both on the back of the property and in front of the church including new lighting and more handicapped parking. A drive-through covered structure was built to allow people to drop off the handicapped or elderly right next to a new ramp leading to the sanctuary. A decorative tower was erected made of stone and a large United Methodist cross and flame accented the tower. Rev. Morris had a vision to enclose the area were the bell tower stood to create a garden area for meditation and prayer, landscaping the area with hedges.
In addition to the outdoor improvements, the sanctuary was updated. Church members, led by member Mark Collins, installed new flooring in the chancel area. The choir pews were moved to one side allowing the altar and cross to become the focal point. The former pipes from the organ were removed revealing two stain glass windows which had been covered by the pipes. Windows were installed on the back wall of the sanctuary revealing the beauty of God’s creation and allowing much-needed light into the worship area.
A long-time member, Glen Alexander, who has a gift for woodworking, created a lectern to match the baptismal fount in the sanctuary. He traced the pattern on the baptismal fount and enlarged it to create the new lectern. As a sentimental gesture, he used wood from the former pipe organ and the pulpit to create the new podium. Mr. Alexander also made the time capsule to imitate the baptismal fount and pulpit design.